Loading...
Choices and Consequences
October 23, 2026 at 12:29 PM
Separate letter delivery outcomes and omit the unsupported ring Dexterity penalty.
Gothic 1 Remake gives the Nameless Hero real decisions: who to side with, who to spare, and which reward to take. Some choices shift your reputation with a camp, some change which gear you walk away with, and a few lock out content for good. This page lists the notable decisions and what each option leads to so you can plan ahead.
Decision | Outcomes |
|---|---|
Casting Shadows (1) Fight Kirgo (2) Fight Kharim | (1) Gain 80 EXP when you defeat him and 150 EXP after telling it to Scatty. Scatty will be impressed if you win. (2) Gain 140 EXP when you defeat him and 200 EXP after telling it to Scatty. Scatty will be very impressed if you win. |
Should You Pay Bloodwyn? (1) Pay Bloodwyn 10 Ore Nuggets (2) Refuse the protection money | (1) Bloodwyn will request another 10 Ore Nuggets every day. (2) Bloodwyn will send a digger to attack the Hero. |
Should You Pay Jackal? (1) Pay Jackal 10 Ore Nuggets (2) Refuse the protection money | (1) Jackal will not extort afterward and will help you if someone is hostile to you. (2) Jackal will not send anyone to attack you as payback but will not offer any protection if someone is hostile to you. |
Test of Faith (1) Buy the map from Graham for 20 Ore Nuggets (2) Threaten Graham to get the map | (1) Obtain the map at the cost of 20 Ore Nuggets. (2) Obtain the map for free. |
Should You Kill Mordrag? (1) Let Mordrag escort you to New Camp (2) Kill Mordrag (3) Beat up Mordrag and tell him to get lost | (1) Obtain 200 EXP after you both reach the New Camp. Mordrag will also give you his ring. (2) Obtain 200 EXP and complete a step for Admission to the Old Camp. You can loot the ring from his body. (3) Obtain 100 EXP and complete a step for Admission to the Old Camp. |
Should You Kill Grim? (1) Kill Grim (2) Spare Grim | (1) Obtain 60 EXP and his loot. (2) Grim can be used for backup to help you out. |
Should You Keep Whistler's Sword? (1) Choose "Weren't you going to sell it for a hundred?" from Fisk (2) Return the Sword to Whistler (3) Keep the 110 Ore Nuggets from Whistler (4) Keep Whistler's Sword (5) Return the 110 Ore Nuggets to Whistler but keep the sword | (1) Fisk refuses to sell Whistler's Sword and the quest fails. (2) Receive 200 EXP and earn points needed to enter the Old Camp. (3) Whistler becomes hostile and will attack you after two days. You can knock him out to get 80 EXP, and you're free to take his loot. (4) The quest fails and deducts the points needed to enter the Old Camp. Whistler does not become hostile. (5) The quest fails and deducts the points needed to enter the Old Camp. Whistler does not become hostile. |
Should You Give the Amulet to Sly? (1) Give the amulet to Sly (2) Don't give the amulet to Sly | (1) Obtain 250 EXP and complete the quest. (2) Sly will keep looking for the amulet and the quest will remain unfinished. |
Should You Keep Mordrag's Ring? (1) Give Mordrag's Ring to Lares (2) Keep Mordrag's Ring | (1) Gain progress on Admission to the New Camp and unlock A Piece of the Pie quest. (2) You can equip the ring to get +5 Dexterity or sell it for a hefty sum. |
Should You Give the List to Lares or Diego? (1) Give the List to Diego immediately (2) Give the List to Lares first | (1) Earn a total of 750 EXP, fail the "Something the Matter?" quest, and lose another option to get Lares's Trust. Finish Casting Shadows, Test of Faith, and make progress to the Admission to the Old Camp quest. (2) Earn a total of 1,750 EXP, finish "Something the Matter?", and earn Lares's Trust. You can still finish Casting Shadows and make progress to the Admission to the Old Camp quest. |
Sealed Letter to Milten | 400 XP. Choose a Ring of Power (+5 Strength), a Ring of Lesser Dexterity (+5 Dexterity), an Essence of Spirit (+2 permanent mana), or the three-scroll package: Fireball, Ball Lightning, and Transform into Fire Lizard. |
Opened Letter to Milten | 300 XP. Choose a Ring of Power (+5 Strength), a Ring of Lesser Dexterity (+5 Dexterity), an Essence of Spirit (+2 permanent mana), or the three-scroll package: Fireball, Ball Lightning, and Transform into Fire Lizard. |
Sealed Letter directly to Torrez | 200 XP and a Ring of Power (+5 Strength). |
Opened Letter directly to Torrez | 100 XP and an Elixir of Healing. |
Should You Get the Healing Rune or Firebolt Rune? (1) Take the Healing Rune (2) Choose the Firebolt Rune | (1) Get the Healing Rune from Torrez (2) Get the Firebolt Rune from Torrez |
Should You Kill Shrike? (1) Spare Shrike (2) Kill Shrike | (1) Complete the quest and get 200 EXP from Gorn. (2) Quest will fail and you won't get the EXP reward |
The biggest branching point is which camp you join, covered on the Main Quests page. Decisions that affect a single quest are noted in Side Quests.
Bloodwyn charges 10 ore each day he catches you after the first payment, until you join the Old Camp. Refusal can bring an attack from a digger. Jackal charges 10 ore once for his district; refusing him brings no retaliatory attacker. If both people in a dispute pay Jackal, he can settle it with a one-on-one fight instead of taking your side.
Let Mordrag escort you to the New Camp to receive his ring and 200 XP while keeping him alive. Grim can also be spared after the ambush in The Amulet; reconciliation leaves him available as backup. For A Roof Over My Head, knock out Shrike, loot his equipment, and spare him to keep Gorn's 200 XP reward.
Decision | Reward Options | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
Baal Kagan after Canvassing Customers | 100 ore nuggets; 3 scrolls; or help joining the Brotherhood | The ore is an additional reward. Scroll choices are Sleep, Charm, Fist of Wind, Pyrokinesis, or Telekinesis, and repeats are allowed. Help provides the Dreamcall quest item for Baal Tyon's approval. |
Y'Berion after The Almanac | 150 ore; 3 Sleep scrolls; or 5 Extracts of Magic Energy | Choose one package. Mana potions also support scroll use. |
Cor Kalom after The Lost Apprentice | Ask for 50 ore or move on without it | He objects to being asked, but the next quest and story continue. |
Y'Berion during The Focus Stone | Ask for the Amulet of Flames | Ask when accepting the task or after returning the stone. If you never ask, you miss this reward. |
Talas during The Almanac | Ask for 30 or 50 ore, or accept no payment | The higher payment does not change the story outcome. |
Xardas' demon | 500 XP for a kill after the Xardas quest | The demon cannot be killed while that quest is still active. Finish the golem tasks and the quest first. |
The Price of Magic lets you choose a Healing Rune or Firebolt Rune after Torrez teaches you the basics. Healing spends mana to restore health; Firebolt gives a ranged attack. Completing the task opens his magic stock, so you can buy the other rune later. Compare current offers rather than treating either option as a fixed resale profit.
In Chapter 5, fighting the castle occupants can provide weapons and access to story-gated equipment. Knocking an NPC unconscious lets you loot them without executing them, though they can recover and fight again. Kills are permanent, so finish outstanding tasks and keep a save before starting a fight. Leaving the outer camp peaceful preserves access to its residents, although some traders may refuse service.