Revision 3

Windrose sets world difficulty at world creation, and the setting applies globally across all biomes. The difficulty cannot be changed after the world is created, making the initial choice an important one. Four presets are available plus a fully custom option.

The Four Presets

Captain's Choice Custom Modifiers

The Captain's Choice setting exposes individual tunable modifiers, letting players design bespoke difficulty profiles. Confirmed modifiers from community research of server configuration options include:

Enemy Level Scaling

Within any difficulty setting, enemy levels scale by island/area rather than per dungeon. Enemies on the second island are level 6 while players may still be level 3, making travel to harder biomes a significant risk-reward decision. The starting Coastal Jungle is tuned for gear tier 1-5, Foothills for tier 6-10, and Cursed Swamps for tier 11-15 regardless of difficulty setting.

Recommended Choices

• First playthrough: High Seas - intended balanced experience

• Casual play: Calm Waters - focus on exploration and base building

• Challenge run: Storm's Edge - tougher combat without full customization

• New Game Plus feel: Captain's Choice with higher multipliers - 2x to 3x enemy HP and damage for experienced players

• Immersive exploration: Captain's Choice with EasyExplore off - disables most map markers

Co-op Considerations

The Coop_StatsCorrectionModifier and Coop_ShipStatsCorrectionModifier automatically scale enemy difficulty based on how many players are in the session. Larger co-op parties face proportionally tougher enemies. This keeps the challenge consistent across solo and multiplayer play. Groups of 4 typically see a modest scaling; the 8-player maximum sees a more significant boost.

World Creation Reminder

The difficulty setting cannot be changed after world creation. If you want to experiment with different difficulty profiles, create a new world (your character progress carries between worlds). This is one of the most important decisions at world creation alongside difficulty selection; consider which modifiers align with your intended playstyle before confirming.

See Also

• Procedural Biomes - biome progression

• Combat - combat mechanics

• Multiplayer - co-op details

• Dedicated Server Hosting - server configuration

Developer Intent Behind the Difficulty Design

The Windrose developers have made their design philosophy explicit in the launch tips: Hard is intentionally hard, and Easy is still challenging. Neither preset is a walkover. This framing is important because Windrose's combat system is Souls-like, with dash, parry, and stamina management at the center. Even the Easy preset expects players to learn those fundamentals rather than brute-force past them.

The practical translation is that picking a difficulty in Windrose is not the same as picking a difficulty in an action game with generous health pools. Calm Waters reduces enemy pressure but does not remove the requirement to dodge and manage stamina. Storm's Edge sharpens the teeth of an already pointed system. Players who are newer to Souls-like combat should expect a learning curve on any preset, and plan to invest time in the dodge and parry rhythm regardless of the slider position.

Why Difficulty Is Tweakable, Not Just Preset

Beyond the four named presets (Calm Waters, High Seas, Storm's Edge, Captain's Choice), Windrose exposes individual difficulty modifiers so players can fine-tune the experience without committing to a fixed bundle. The developers explicitly encouraged tweaking these individual settings to find a personal fit rather than locking into one of the preset names. The Captain's Choice option is the delivery mechanism for this granular control.

A common example: a co-op group that enjoys the enemy health pools of High Seas but finds enemy damage punishing can keep MobHealthMultiplier at 1.0 and drop MobDamageMultiplier to 0.8. A solo player who wants boss fights to feel tighter without making trash mobs unkillable can pump BoardingDifficultyMultiplier without touching the open-world mob modifiers. The sliders let the world feel calibrated to the group rather than to an abstract "normal" baseline.

Recommended Starting Point for Co-Op Servers

The community-tested default for co-op servers is High Seas, which applies all modifiers at 100% and matches the balanced experience the developers tuned the game around. From there, the recommendation is to play a couple of sessions at the preset, identify what feels off (enemies too tanky, ships too fragile, boarding fights too swingy), and drop into Captain's Choice to nudge the specific modifiers without overhauling the whole profile.

Solo players on their first run benefit from the same approach. If the starter combat feels overwhelming, lowering MobDamageMultiplier or CombatDifficulty incrementally is healthier than dropping to Calm Waters outright, because it preserves the enemy HP pool (and therefore the pacing) while taking some of the edge off incoming damage.

How the Developer Intent Maps to the Sliders

• Hard is intentionally hard. Storm's Edge and Captain's Choice with multipliers at 1.5x or above are meant to feel demanding. Do not expect gear alone to compensate; the expectation is that the player has mastered dodges and parries before leaning into these settings.

• Easy is still challenging. Calm Waters remains a Souls-like at its core. Stamina management still matters; the game does not stop being a dodge-and-counter game because multipliers are below 100%.

• Normal (High Seas) is the intended balance. All sliders at 100% represent the tuning the developers shipped. Treat it as the calibration point and adjust from there.

• Fine-tune, do not jump presets. The developer-encouraged approach is to shift individual modifiers until the difficulty curve feels right. Switching from High Seas to Calm Waters overshoots; using Captain's Choice to drop one or two sliders by 10% to 20% is usually enough.

Difficulty and the Free Respec Loop

Because attribute respec is completely free, a player who finds a chosen difficulty harder than expected has a second lever to pull before touching the sliders: rebuilding the character. Pouring attribute points into Vitality and Endurance through respec often provides enough survivability to handle a preset that felt too punishing on a glass-cannon build. Only after the build is already tuned does it make sense to lower the world modifiers.

Quick Reference: Developer-Intent Summary

• Easy is not a cakewalk. Expect to learn dodges and parries on any preset.

• Hard is genuinely hard. Storm's Edge and high Captain's Choice multipliers punish unprepared builds.

• Tweak individual sliders. Captain's Choice exists so players can avoid the all-or-nothing feel of the presets.

• Normal is the balance target. High Seas reflects the developers' intended tuning and is the best starting point for co-op.

• Locked after world creation. The difficulty choice cannot be edited in-game; only the next new world can change it.

Difficulty Name Reference

Four preset difficulty tiers plus a custom tier cover the range:

Selection Window

Difficulty is only editable at new-world creation. Once the world is saved and loaded, the preset choice is locked even for Captain's Choice. Changing the target experience level later requires starting a fresh world. The one flag that stays soft is Shared Quest Progress, which can be turned on alongside any preset. Enabling Shared Quest Progress while sitting on a preset other than Captain's Choice automatically moves the world into Captain's Choice.