This article is incomplete
Some sections are missing or need additional details. Help improve it by contributing.
Captain Stede Bonnet opens after Marooned. Read Bonnet's First Letter in the fireplace room of the Great Inagua manor. The letter sends Edward to inspect Bonnet's ship and crew on Mystery Island at (907,123), on the eastern edge of Navassa.
Find The Revenge
Approach the island without straying too far south toward its Legendary Ship encounter. After docking, swim ashore and head northwest to the mangrove beach. Investigate The Revenge and approach its trapdoor to meet Rowland Sharp. After the campfire scene, follow the loyal crew to the mutineers.
Defeat both groups
At the shore confrontation, Edward can wait for the dialogue or attack the mutineers. After they are defeated, fight the British soldiers who arrive on the beach. Stay ashore: they swim in, so returning to the Jackdaw is unnecessary.
Title Update 1.0.8 (October 27, 2026) fixed an issue where the loyalists would not move if Edward took an alternative route.
Search the flooded cabin
Follow the loyal crew back to the schooner. Sharp gives Edward the cabin key. Pass through the flooded quarters and interact with the barricaded door. The room contains Bonnet's diary, sugar, and a pardon letter. Inspect the letter with the dagger on the desk to obtain Bonnet's Portrait, Bonnet's Dagger, and his Final Letter.
Complete the quest
Return to the Great Inagua manor basement and place the portrait in the collection. The portrait and dagger become part of Edward's display.
Character Portraits gives the requirements for completing the manor gallery.
Side Quests includes the other optional portrait quests.