Revision 1

Settlers are the heart of My Time at Evershine. The game flips the series' usual setup: instead of arriving as the newcomer in an established town, the player is the founder, and everyone else is the new arrival. Characters met out in the world can be brought back to the settlement, given a home, and put to work. The game is unreleased, so the systems described here are announced design and may change.

How recruitment works

Pathea has described the flow in a development Q&A: you meet intriguing characters along your travels, bring them back to your growing settlement, and invite them to join. As they settle in, they offer advice and assistance and gradually open up their own stories. Recruitment is also tied to construction. If you want a blacksmith in town, and access to their forge, you first need to build a smithy; once it stands, the blacksmith becomes a steady member of the community.

Some characters are introduced by the main quest, others through sidequests or recruitment out in the world, and a few are hidden.

The three tiers of NPCs

Pathea laid out a tier system for the cast in an October 2024 development post:

1. Core romanceables. A small group introduced by the main story, with the most content across the main plot and their own relationship arcs. See romance and relationships.

2. Named characters. Some twenty-plus unique characters introduced through the main quest, sidequests, and recruitment, some of them hidden. Each has a unique relationship story, just with less content than the core group. Pathea has said it stays flexible if any of them turn out to be especially popular.

3. Random NPCs. A pool of randomly generated settlers with random traits, mostly found through recruiting. They can share common relationship arcs but do not get unique ones.

Mainline NPCs and story arcs are fixed; everyone gets them, and they cannot be kicked out of the settlement. Everything else varies, and Pathea is leaning on that for replay value. The settlement's makeup is never the same twice, and different mixes of characters in a scene produce different dialogue.

Jobs and assignments

Once settlers are in town, the Governor assigns them to jobs. Suitability matters: a good fighter may not be a good farmer, and picking roles badly has consequences. A few settlers at a time can also be assigned as followers, accompanying the player in battle, resource gathering, and construction.

Wellbeing and morale

Settlers have opinions and share them. Residents will let the Governor know if the cook is ruining dishes, if they are not getting enough sleep, or if the entertainment is not particularly entertaining. Angry workers are, in Pathea's words, not conducive to a good settlement. Back in 2024 the team also floated a hard mode in which all settlers are extra cranky and hard to appease; that idea was described as under consideration and has not been confirmed since.

Settlers with stories

Pathea's stated theme for the game is that no matter where people are from or what happened in their past, everyone comes together to make a new home that belongs to them. The writers favor characters who start with problems and work through them over the course of the story, and they have warned that some of these stories get a bit dark. The setting helps: people willing to move to the fringes of the Alliance, next to an antagonistic empire, tend to be people with nowhere better to go.

Only a handful of settlers have been named in official text so far. Hua, a settler tied to a blacksmith quest, appears in the alpha build. Avery shows up in official preview material, and Freya was the first character modeled in the game's new art style. Funded stretch goals also promise visits from familiar series faces, including Logan and the backer-voted Fang; all stretch goal content is planned rather than final.

Making settlers feel alive

Alpha feedback hit this system hard. Players said new arrivals went straight to work with almost no interaction, coming across, in Pathea's own summary, as task bots. The studio has documented the complaints and outlined fixes: town specialists will arrive with a proper introduction and a welcome gift, such as a choice of weapons from the blacksmith or an inventory-expanding bag from the tailor. And if you give a settler a gift, they may display it in their home, so the friendship leaves a visible mark. These changes were announced in a March 2026 development update and are still in progress.