Loading...
Choices and Consequences - Version 1 vs Version 2
Nov 20, 2026, 12:08 AM
Created page covering the eight story choices in Chapters 1 and 2, with a summary table and the result of every option
Nov 20, 2026, 02:08 AM
Corrected the Hey Arnold! choice: killing Arnold moves Jason toward a Hardened profile, 'Restrained' is not a profile rating, and Arnold leaves the story whichever option you pick
1-Several story Missions in Grand Theft Auto VI stop for a moment and give you a choice. Most of these arrive as a timed prompt: you either press the prompt to act, or leave it alone and let the timer run out, which counts as the other answer. A few of them change your Criminal Profile or your relationship with Lucia Caminos, and one may decide whether a character turns up again later. Others only change a line of dialogue or an outfit. This page covers every choice identified so far in Chapter 1 and Chapter 2, mission by mission, with what each option does.1+Several story Missions in Grand Theft Auto VI stop for a moment and give you a choice. Most of these arrive as a timed prompt: you either press the prompt to act, or leave it alone and let the timer run out, which counts as the other answer. A few of them change your Criminal Profile or your relationship with Lucia Caminos, and one moves Jason toward a harsher profile. Others only change a line of dialogue or an outfit. This page covers every choice identified so far in Chapter 1 and Chapter 2, mission by mission, with what each option does.2233Story missions cannot be replayed once they are done, so a choice you make is the one you keep for that playthrough. If you want a second try, keep a manual save at the start of each chapter. See Can You Replay Missions? and Saving and Loading.4455All Choices at a Glance667-ChoiceMissionOptionsEffectSleeping with MandyPipework (Chapter 1)No choice is offeredYou cannot sleep with Mandy during this mission.Kill or spare ArnoldHey Arnold! (Chapter 1)Kill Arnold, spare Arnold, or waitKilling him gives Jason a Hardened rating and ends any further contact. Sparing him gives a Restrained rating and may lead to a later meeting. Waiting lets him swim away.Answer the deposit questionBuck Me (Chapter 1)Say Nothing or Saved CashNo effect. The bank turns Jason and Lucia down either way; only Jason's lines change.Shake Mattia's handDay Release (Chapter 1)Shake, or let the timer run outNo effect. Mattia does not react if you refuse.Pick Lucia's dressDay Release (Chapter 1)Black, Gold or BrownSets what Lucia wears for the night out at the club in Vice City.Accept Mattia's drugsDay Release (Chapter 1)Accept, or let the timer run outNo effect. The club scenes and Lucia's hallway sequence play out the same.Mention Brian's retirementSwamped (Chapter 1)Mention it, or let the timer run outMentioning it raises the relationship with Lucia and avoids a fight in Recalibration. Staying quiet leads to that fight and a relationship drop.Hand over the necklaceOvernight Charges (Chapter 2)Give it, or let the timer run outNo difference. Without $900 for the rent, Lucia gives Linda the necklace whichever you pick.7+ChoiceMissionOptionsEffectSleeping with MandyPipework (Chapter 1)No choice is offeredYou cannot sleep with Mandy during this mission.Kill or spare ArnoldHey Arnold! (Chapter 1)Kill Arnold, spare Arnold, or waitKilling him moves Jason toward a Hardened criminal profile. Sparing him, or waiting until he swims away, avoids that. Arnold leaves the story either way; a later reappearance after sparing him has not been confirmed.Answer the deposit questionBuck Me (Chapter 1)Say Nothing or Saved CashNo effect. The bank turns Jason and Lucia down either way; only Jason's lines change.Shake Mattia's handDay Release (Chapter 1)Shake, or let the timer run outNo effect. Mattia does not react if you refuse.Pick Lucia's dressDay Release (Chapter 1)Black, Gold or BrownSets what Lucia wears for the night out at the club in Vice City.Accept Mattia's drugsDay Release (Chapter 1)Accept, or let the timer run outNo effect. The club scenes and Lucia's hallway sequence play out the same.Mention Brian's retirementSwamped (Chapter 1)Mention it, or let the timer run outMentioning it raises the relationship with Lucia and avoids a fight in Recalibration. Staying quiet leads to that fight and a relationship drop.Hand over the necklaceOvernight Charges (Chapter 2)Give it, or let the timer run outNo difference. Without $900 for the rent, Lucia gives Linda the necklace whichever you pick.88Chapter 1 Choices991010Pipework: Sleeping With Mandy11111212During Pipework, Jason collects rent from a tenant named Mandy. There is no option to sleep with her in this mission, so nothing here affects the story.13131414Hey Arnold!: Kill or Spare Arnold15151616Hey Arnold! ends with Jason cornering Arnold on the dock outside Jason's house. You can kill him to keep him quiet, or spare him and trust his promise to say nothing. This is one of the first permanent choices in the story.171718-OptionResultKill ArnoldJason gets a Hardened criminal rating at the end of the mission. It moves him away from the cleanest end of the profile spectrum, though he is still a long way from Irredeemable. You also lose any chance of dealing with Arnold again.Spare ArnoldJason gets a Restrained criminal rating. There is a chance Arnold appears again in a later story mission.Wait it outArnold says he will just swim away. This plays out much like sparing him.18+OptionResultKill ArnoldJason is moved toward a Hardened criminal profile at the end of the mission. That is a step away from Professional, the cleanest of the five profiles, though still a long way from Irredeemable.Spare ArnoldArnold swims off and Jason assures Brian he will cause no more trouble, which satisfies Brian. Jason's profile is not pushed toward Hardened.Wait it outArnold says he will just swim away. This plays out the same as sparing him.19-Sparing Arnold makes no visible difference in Chapter 1: the closing cutscene of the mission is the same whatever you pick. If you want to keep the possibility of meeting him again, and keep Jason's profile on the restrained side, spare him.19+The closing cutscene of the mission is the same whatever you pick. Arnold is not reported to appear again either way, and a later meeting after sparing him has not been confirmed. If you want to keep Jason's profile closer to Professional, spare him.20202121Buck Me: Say Nothing or Saved Cash22222323In Buck Me, Jason and Lucia sit down with a bank manager to open accounts and try to get a loan for their house. When the manager asks whether they have any kind of deposit to put down, you get a timed choice between Say Nothing and Saved Cash.24242525OptionResultSay NothingThe manager refuses the accounts. Only Jason's dialogue before the refusal is different.Saved CashThe manager still refuses the accounts.2626Neither answer helps. Both end with the manager rejecting the application because of the couple's credit, so pick whichever line you prefer. For how banking works once the story moves on, see How to Open a Bank Account.27272828Day Release: Shake Mattia's Hand29293030In Day Release, Jason and Lucia spend time with Mattia, hoping that getting on his good side will lead to better-paying work. When they meet, Mattia says the two of them could be good friends and offers Jason his hand.31313232OptionResultShakeJason shakes Mattia's hand and the mission carries on.Let the timer run outJason does not shake his hand. Mattia shows no reaction and nothing changes.3333The prompt looks important, but the mission continues the same way either way.34343535Day Release: Black, Gold or Brown Dress36363737Later in Day Release you choose one of three dresses for Lucia: Black, Gold or Brown. The only effect is what she wears when the pair go clubbing in Vice City.38383939Day Release: Accept the Drugs40404141During the club part of Day Release, Mattia offers Jason and Lucia a hit of an unnamed drug. To accept, press the prompt. To refuse, leave it until the timer runs out.42424343OptionResultAcceptJason and Lucia both take the drug before heading to the dance floor. The mission then goes on as normal.Let the timer run outNeither of them takes it, and the club sequence goes on as normal.4444Nothing changes either way. The cutscenes that follow are identical, and the dreamlike hallway sequence with Lucia near the end of the club section still happens if you refused, so it comes from the drinking rather than the drug. See Drugs and Their Effects.45454646Swamped: Mention Brian's Retirement47474848After Swamped, Brian tells Jason he is going straight and retiring from the drug running business. About a week later, back at the house in Key Lento, Jason gets the chance to tell Lucia about it. The subject comes up again in Recalibration, when Cal mentions it, and how Jason and Lucia react depends on what you chose here.49495050OptionResultMention Brian's retirementThe relationship with Lucia goes up. When Cal raises the subject in Recalibration, Lucia backs Jason up on the drive home, and the pair avoid a fight at the end of that mission.Let the timer run outJason and Lucia have a big argument at the end of Recalibration, and the relationship level drops once it plays out.5151Tell her. Mentioning the retirement is the only option that protects the relationship, and staying quiet costs you a relationship level later. See Sex and Romance for how the relationship levels work.52525353Chapter 2 Choices54545555Overnight Charges: Give Linda the Necklace56565757At the start of Chapter 2, Lucia has to settle the room bill with Linda, the manager of the Starlet Motel. The rent is $900. If you cannot cover it, Linda asks for something as collateral until you can pay, and suggests Lucia's necklace. A timed prompt then appears to hand it over.58585959OptionResultGive the necklaceLucia hands it over and gets more time to pay the rent.Let the timer run outLucia gives up the necklace anyway, because she has no real choice.6060Unless you already have the $900, the necklace goes to Linda whatever you do. You can get it back by paying off the debt later in Chapter 2; see Behind on Payments. For ways to raise the money, see How to Make Money Fast.